Martyrs or Victims?

By Dr. Helmy Al-Faqi December 07, 2024 3017

 

Jihad for the sake of Allah is one of the noblest acts of worship and among the best ways a servant can draw closer to the Lord of the Worlds. It is the peak of Islam, as mentioned in the Hadith of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) to Mu'adh: “Shall I not inform you of the head of the matter, its pillar and its peak?” I said, “Yes, O Messenger of Allah.” He (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said, “The head of the matter is Islam, its pillar is the prayer and its peak is jihad.” (Narrated by Ahmad, At-Tirmidhi, and Ibn Majah)

Abu Dharr (may Allah be pleased with him) said: I asked, “Messenger of Allah, which of the deeds is the best?” He (the Holy Prophet) replied: “Belief in Allah and Jihad in His cause.” (Narrated by Al-Bukhari and Muslim). Abu Sa’id Al-Khudri (may Allah be pleased with him) reported that a man came to the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) and said, “Who is the best of men?” He said, “A man who fights in the way of Allah spending his wealth and staking his life.”

Given the status of jihad for the sake of Allah, dying in His cause is a death that a sincere believer aspires for Allah to grant him, due to the status a martyr holds with Allah. Anas ibn Malik reported that the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said: “Nobody who enters Paradise will (ever like to) return to this world even if he were offered everything on the surface of the earth (as an inducement) except the martyr who will desire to return to this world and be killed ten times for the sake of the great honour that has been bestowed upon him.” (Narrated by Muslim)

Martyrs are of two types: martyrs of this world and the Hereafter, and martyrs of the Hereafter only. The former are those killed in battle between Muslims and disbelievers. The latter include many categories such as those who drown, those who die in a building collapse, those who burn to death, those who die of stomach disease, and those unjustly killed.

 

The Casualties of Gaza: Martyrs or Victims?

Those who die from Gaza fighting the Zionist enemy are undoubtedly martyrs, unanimously agreed upon by scholars. As for the civilians from Gaza who are not combatants, whether men, children, or women, they are considered martyrs according to all scholars; I know of no disagreement on this. Anyone who says they are victims and not martyrs is entirely wrong.

Evidence for their status as martyrs includes:

  1. Ibn Abbas reported that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) said: “Whoever is killed defending himself against injustice, he is a martyr.” (Narrated by Ahmad in his Musnad, and authenticated by Sheikh Ahmad Shakir). The civilians of Gaza, who were not combatants, were killed defending their rights, thus they are martyrs in the sight of Allah.
  2. Umar ibn Al-Khattab used to say: “O Allah! I ask you for martyrdom in Your way and death in the city of Your Messenger!” (Narrated by Al-Bukhari in his Sahih, and Malik in his Muwatta). Ibn Abd al-Barr in Al-Istidhkar stated: This indicates that one who is unjustly killed is a martyr, for Umar was killed in the prayer mihrab, praying, unjustly, and he is a martyr, because the unjustly killed is a martyr and the people of Gaza were killed unjustly and oppressively.
  3. Ibn Umar reported that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) said: “If anyone goes to a man of my community in order to kill him, he should say in this way, the one who kills will go to Hell and the one who is killed will go to Paradise.” (Narrated by Ahmad and Abu Dawood) This clearly indicates that the unjustly killed Muslim is in Paradise by Allah's permission, and the people of Gaza were killed unjustly.
  4. Ibn Hajar in Fath Al-Bari stated: The unjustly killed person's sins are expiated by the killing, as mentioned in the report authenticated by Ibn Hibban and others: “The sword obliterates errors.” (Narrated by Al-Darimi, Ibn Hibban, Al-Bayhaqi in Al-Sunan, and Al-Tabarani in Al-Kabir, and authenticated by Ibn Hibban and others). Ibn Mas’ud said: “When the killing occurs, it wipes out everything.” (Narrated by Al-Tabarani in Al-Kabir, and Abdul-Razzaq in his Musannaf, and similarly from Al-Hasan ibn Ali; Al-Bazzar narrated from Aisha in a hadith marfu’, “No killing passes by a sin without erasing it”).

In conclusion, an unjustly killed person is a martyr without any disagreement that I know of. The only dispute is whether he is a martyr of this world and the Hereafter or only of the Hereafter. The Hanafi and Hanbali scholars state that the unjustly killed is a martyr of both, as stated by Al-Sarakhsi in Al-Mabsut (2/52): “The unjustly killed is not washed,” and the author of Al-Furu' in Hanbali fiqh (3/299) said: “The unjustly killed is not washed, according to the sound opinion.”

 

-------------------------------------------------------------

Read the Article in Arabic

 

hacklink al hack forum organik hit kayseri escort erotik film izlemarsbahisdeneme bonusu veren siteleropenbook market idMostbet+18 filmcasinolevantdeneme bonusu veren sitelermariobet girişgecelikpijama takımıbetbababetivosultanbet girişbtcbahiscasinomegabetbaba girişdeneme bonusu veren sitelercasino siteleriultrabetGrandpashabettipobet girişselçuksportsonline casinobelugabahis girişlilibet norgelilibet norgeindia online bettingbest online casino indiaMikiカジノ 評判Mikiカジノオンカジ 入金不要ボーナスbelugabahis girişrulet siteleriligobet girişkedicasino levantcasinolevantcasinolevantDeneme Bonusu Veren SitelerGrandpashabetcrypto casinobitcoin casinosbest online casino canadasports betting ontariocanadian online casinocrypto casinosGrandpashabetbetnanobetting sitesonline bettingonline casinonew online casinoPornolk21roblox fisch scriptxeno executorsweet bonanzadeneme bonusu veren sitelerimajbet1461. comimajbet1461. comimajbet1461. comimajbet1461. comimajbet1461. comgrandpashabet 2221grandpashabet 2221jojobetRoku Bet güncel girişmatadorbet girişcasibom girişbetlike girişbetplay girişdizipalgrandpashabetGrandpashabetayvalık zeytinyağıhd pornotobetbetebetpusulabetotobetbetebetmatbetgrandbettingotobetdumanbetmarsbahissekabetspincofilm seyretcasibomporn izle doedaAltın Fiyatları Forexcasibom girişcasibom girişdeneme bonusu veren sitelerElexbetbetturkeyxslotzbahisonwinonwinonwinonwinzbahismeritking girişgrandpashabetgrandpashabetzbahisbahsegel girişnakitbahis girişbetebetsekabetvaycasinoultrabetmavibetkulisbet girişsüperbahissüperbahisvaycasinovaycasino güncel girişbetturkey güncel girişmadridbet girişbetkanyon girişdumanbet güncel girişbets10romabetbetebetbetosferbetnispinbahisbetpuandumanbetdeneme bonusu veren sitelerasyabahisbetturkey giriştarafbetgalabet girişherabetherabet girişgalabet güncel girişvaycasino güncel girişvaycasinoroyalbetcasibombetkombetkom girişbetkom güncel girişkralbet girişTanıtım Yazısıtrendbetcasibomimajbet güncelsnaptwittercasibom girişjojobetmarsbahissahabetjojobetjojobetsahabetbahigomarsbahismarsbahiskalebetpusulabettempobetmeritbetjojobetjojobet girişjojobetmarsbahisvaycasinoonwincasibom güncelimajbetjojobetholiganbetcasibom güncelbetebetextrabet girişmeritking girişmeritbet girişpusulabet girişmarsbahis girişmarsbahissahabetsahabetmarsbahiswindows vds satın aldeneme bonusu veren siteler forumcasibomparibahis girişasyabahissekabetcasibom girişbets10taraftarium24justin tvselçuksportsbetyap girişbetyap girişcasinomhubdeneme bonusu veren sitelerbettiltbettiltwbahisdumanbettempobethiltonbetsu kaçağı tespiticasibom pornomavibet girişmavibet girişqueenbetbetasus1xbetcasibomlivebahisonwin 1763grandpashabet2220 commatadorbet750 combetparkgrandpashabet 2221fixbet twitterfixbetfixbet girişlivebahislivebahislivebahislivebahistipobetcasibom girişasyabahis girişasyabahis güncel girişasyabahisimajbet1314bets10imajbet1475454 marsbahissekabet1273 comgrandpashabet 2221bettilt casinoNakitbahisamexgiftcard/balancepopüler bahis siteleripaslanmaz çelikcasibomsetrabetTarafbetbahis siteleritoy poodlevaycasinobetturkeyjojobetbethandhdfilmcehennemiextrabetSekabet girişbetpark girişbahissenindumanbet girişimajbet girişbetpark girişdumanbet girişbettiltbettilt güncelcanlı casino siteleriBetpasmarsbahisgate of olympus oynaBetsatBetsat Girişfree instagram followersinstagram takipçi hilesiGoal Securitysüperbahisdeneme bonusu veren sitelersüperbahisdeneme bonusu, bedava deneme bonusu veren sitelerdeneme bonusu veren sitelercasinomhub girişbetpark yeni girişasyabahis güncel girişasyabahisasyabahis girişEsenyurt EscortotobetEXTRABETpadişahbetprimebahisGates Of Olympussportazabettiltprimebahisimajbetimajbetbetbigo girişcasibom güncel girişaydin escortmanisa escortvaycasinobetebetdeneme bonusuradissonbetatlasbetcasibomcasibom girişbahiscasinovaycasinoboşşinat tv canlı maç izleprime bahisradissonbetcasibomkaçak maç izlecanlı maç izlegüvenilir casino sitelerien güvenilir casino siteleriolabahis girişbasari betprimebahisterea sigaraelektronik sigarabetturkeynakitbahis girişcasibom güncel girişcasibom güncel girişcasibombahiscomcasibom güncel girişnakitbahiscasibom güncel girişotobetcasibom girişjojobetgüvenilir casino siteleriparibahis girişbahis sitelericasibomSakarya escortSakarya escortprimebahisiptvcasibomcasibom girişSekabet giriştwidropperbahiscasinobetriyalbetsat1xbetcasibom girişcasibomDeneme Bonusu Veren Sitelercasino siteleribahis siteleriprostadinefree porn deneme bonusu veren sitelerfixbetbetgaranticasibom 719 com girişcasibom 719 com girişfixbetgrandpashabet먹튀위크tarafbetmatbetsekabet güncelmarsbahisjojobetcasibomcasinolevant girişsekabetfree vpn pcblox fruits scriptbeylikdüzü escortaresbet girişbetparkmeritbet girişmarsbahisatlasbet girişPadişahbetPadişahbetcasinomhub güncel girişhd film izleBetgarantiExtrabetBetparknakitbahisizmir escortextrabetAvrupa yakası escortEsenyurt escortBeylikdüzü escortAvcılar escortSnaptikvevobahisSu Kaçağı Tespiticasibomcasibom güncel giriştürk porno , türk ifşadumanbetwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftgiftcardmall/mygiftgiftcardmall/mygiftwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftjojobetidata randevusekabetonwinsahabetmarsbahisjojobetmarsbahismarsbahis girişzbahis onwinnowwin girişaxbet girişkulisbet girişarzbet girişbeşiktaş escortonwinzbahis zagabet girişbizbet girişlunabet girişbetturkeyvaycasinomatadorbetfixbet girişbetciobettiltcratosslotwinxbetultrabethazbetmavibetrüyabetpusulabetzbahis twitterzbahis güncel girişzbahis girişzbahis twitter girişicasibomzbahisbetturkeySekabetistanbul escortvbetcasibomcasibom güncel girişvaycasinofixbetcasibomataşehir escortaaaCasibombetturkeymitolyn reviewmitolynmarsbahissahabetimajbetmatbetmarsbahisdeneme bonusu veren sitelerjojobetmarsbahisjojobetdinimi porn virin sex sitilirijojobetjojobet girişholiganbet