Huawei: Uighur surveillance fears lead PR exec to quit

One of Huawei's European communications managers has resigned from the Chinese firm over concerns about its role in the surveillance of Muslim Uighurs.

Tommy Zwicky had worked in the company's Danish office for six months and was a former journalist.

It comes after internal Huawei documents were made public, which mentioned a "Uighur alarm" system that it had worked on with Chinese facial-recognition specialist Megvii in 2018.

Huawei said it opposed discrimination.

"We provide general-purpose connectivity products based on recognised industry standards, and we comply with ethics and governance systems around emerging technology," it told the BBC.

"We do not develop or sell systems that identify people by their ethnicity, and we do not condone the use of our technologies to discriminate against or oppress members of any community."

A spokeswoman for Megvii declined to comment, but the firm has previously said its systems are not designed to target or label specific ethnic groups.

It is believed that the Chinese government has detained up to a million Uighurs in Xinjiang province in what the state defines as "re-education camps".

Beijing has consistently denied mistreatment and says the camps are designed to stamp out terrorism and improve employment opportunities.

Disputed title

Mr Zwicky had previously worked for a Danish newspaper, and before that was editor-in-chief of the Danish Broadcasting Corporation.

He officially remains under contract to Huawei until February and is unable to discuss his decision further.

He first announced his departure via Twitter and LinkedIn.

Following this, his boss characterised Mr Zwicky as being a low-level PR manager and Huawei also took issue with Mr Zwicky being described as a vice president of communications, as this signifies a senior role in its corporate structure.

However, articles published at the time of his appointment referred to the fact that this specific title had indeed been created for Mr Zwicky and quoted the chief of Huawei Denmark as saying: "Tommy is a well-known and respected name in the Danish media. With him on board, we feel confident that we can take communication to a new level."

When asked about this, Mr Zwicky told the BBC: "My title was vice president of communications at Huawei Denmark. I have no further comments."

His decision comes a week after French football star Antoine Griezmann ended his sponsorship deal with Huawei after raising his own concerns about "strong suspicions" that the company had been involved in developing an alert system to monitor the Uighurs.

'Confidential' tests

American surveillance research firm IPVM brought to light the Chinese-language documents on 8 December.

They were marked as confidential but were being hosted publicly on Huawei's European website.

The report referenced an "interoperability test [in which] Huawei and Megvii jointly provided a face-recognition solution based on Huawei's video cloud solution. In the solution, Huawei provided servers, storage, network equipment, its FusionSphere cloud platform, cameras and other software and hardware, [while] Megvii provided its dynamic facial-recognition system software".

Among the functions of Megvii's software that the report said Huawei had verified was a "Uighur alert".

IPVM said a separate box added to Megvii's software was capable of determining ethnicity as part of its "face attribute analysis".

The page became inaccessible shortly after the Washington Post asked the firm about its existence.

At the time Huawei said the document had referenced a "test", which had not seen a real-world application.

But the the Post later published a second article which said Huawei's site indicated it had worked with four other companies on products advertised to have ethnicity-tracking capabilities.

In response, Huawei promised to carry out a follow-up investigation, but continued to deny it sold systems that identified people by their ethnicity.

Unsatisfactory response

Concerns about both firm's activities in this area date back further,

The US added Megvii to a trade blacklist in 2019 over concerns that its tech was being used by the Chinese authorities to carry out "repression, mass arbitrary detention, and high-technology surveillance".

And the same year, a group of 13 UK MPs and members of the House of Lords published a letter raising concerns that Huawei was "facilitating a programme of ethnic repression" against the Uighurs.

The BBC has been told that about this time, Westerners working for the firm asked head office for more details about work it was doing for the Chinese authorities in Xinjiang and felt they had never got a satisfactory answer.

But one noted that this it was not uncommon for companies to be wary about discussing sensitive matters with staff./BBC

Last modified on Thursday, 17 December 2020 02:02
hacklink al hack forum organik hit kayseri escort erotik film izlemarsbahisdeneme bonusu veren siteleropenbook market idMostbet+18 filmcasinolevantdeneme bonusu veren sitelermariobet girişgecelikpijama takımıbetbababetivosultanbet girişbtcbahiscasinomegabetbaba girişdeneme bonusu veren sitelercasino siteleriultrabetGrandpashabettipobet girişselçuksportsonline casinobelugabahis girişlilibet norgelilibet norgeindia online bettingbest online casino indiaMikiカジノ 評判Mikiカジノオンカジ 入金不要ボーナスbelugabahis girişrulet siteleriligobet girişkedicasino levantcasinolevantcasinolevantDeneme Bonusu Veren Siteler 2025Grandpashabetcrypto casinobitcoin casinosbest online casino canadasports betting ontariocanadian online casinocrypto casinosGrandpashabetbetnanobetting sitesonline bettingonline casinonew online casinoPornolk21solara executorxeno executorsweet bonanzadeneme bonusu veren sitelercasibom771 comcasibom771 comcasibom771 comcasibom771 comcasibom771 comcasibom771casibom771jojobetRoku Bet güncel girişbetturkey girişcasibom girişbetlike girişbetturkey girişhdfilmcehennemigrandpashabetGrandpashabetayvalık zeytinyağıporn izle doedacasibom girişdeneme bonusu veren sitelerElexbetgay pornolarısexpornocasibomcasibomcasibomcasibomaltyazili pornojojobetmeritkingmeritkingaltyazili pornoimajbetbetkanyonbetebetsekabetmadridbet girişultrabetmavibetkulisbet girişmarsbahismarsbahisbetkanyonkulisbet girişnakitbahismadridbet girişbetkanyon girişdumanbet güncel girişbets10romabetbetebetslotbarhiltonbetbetasusstarzbetbetciograndpashabetbetpasbetturkey güncel giriştarafbetgalabet girişmakrobetmakrobet girişgalabet güncel girişbetkanyon güncelbetkanyonmarsbahiscasibom 771 com girisbetkombetkom girişbetkom güncel girişkralbet girişTanıtım Yazısıbetturkeydinamobetimajbet güncelsnaptwittercasibomjojobetmarsbahisjojobet girişbahsegel girişjojobetpiabellacasino girişmeritbet girişmarsbahismarsbahiskalebetpusulabetasyabahisdinamobet girişmatbetbetmoontempobet girişhiltonbetvaycasinoonwinjojobettipobet güncel girişjojobettipobet girişjojobetbetebetextrabet girişvaycasino girişultrabet girişnakitbahis güncel girişfixbet girişmariobettipobet giriştipobet girişbahsegelredditdeneme bonusu veren siteler forumcasibombettilt giriş güncelasyabahissekabetMATADORBET GİRİŞselçuksportstaraftarium24justin tvselçuksportsrealbahis girişrealbahis girişcasinomhubdeneme bonusu veren sitelerbettiltbettiltceltabetbetasusbetgitmatbetsu kaçağı tespiticasibom pornoZBAHİSmavibet girişmilanobetkulisbet1xbetcasibomlivebahisonwin 1763grandpashabet2220 commatadorbet750 combetparkcasibom771fixbet twitterfixbetfixbet girişlivebahislivebahislivebahislivebahisvaycasinomarsbahis girişasyabahis girişasyabahis güncel girişasyabahistipobet güncel giriş1314bets10imajbet1475454 marsbahissekabet1273 comcasibom771bettilt casinoNakitbahisamexgiftcard/balancepopüler bahis siteleripaslanmaz çelikcasibomsetrabetTarafbetbahis siteleritoy poodlejojobetbetturkeyjojobetbethandhdfilmcehennemiextrabetSekabet girişbetpark girişbahisseninkolaybet girişimajbet girişbetpark girişdumanbet girişbettiltbettilt güncelcanlı casino siteleriAtlasbetmarsbahisgate of olympus oynaAtlasbet GirişAtlasbet Girişfree instagram followersinstagram takipçi hilesiBetturkeymarsbahisdeneme bonusu veren sitelermarsbahisdeneme bonusu, bedava deneme bonusu veren sitelerfixbetcasinomhub girişbetpark yeni girişasyabahis yeni adresasyabahis yeni girişasyabahis güncel adresEsenyurt EscortotobetZBAHİSpadişahbetprimebahisBetkanyonsportazabettiltprimebahisimajbetimajbetbetbigo girişcasibom güncel girişaydin escortmanisa escortvaycasinobetebetdeneme bonusuradissonbetatlasbetcasibomcasibom girişbahiscasinotürk ifşaboşinat tv canlı maç izleprime bahisradissonbetcasibomkaçak maç izlecanlı maç izlegüvenilir casino sitelerien güvenilir casino siteleriolabahis girişbasari betprimebahisterea sigaraelektronik sigarabetturkeyotobetcasibomcasibom girişbetlike girişparibahis girişbahis sitelericasibomSakarya escortSakarya escortprimebahisiptvcasibomcasibomSekabet giriştwidropperbahiscasinobetriyalkingroyalcasibom girişcasibom girişcasibomDeneme Bonusu Veren Siteler 2025casino siteleribahis siteleriprostadine on amazon​free porn deneme bonusu veren sitelerfixbetbetgaranticasibom 719 com girişcasibom771 comfixbetgrandpashabet먹튀위크tarafbetbetturkey girişsekabet güncelcasinolevant girişholiganbetxeno executorroblox executoraresbetmeritbet girişcasinomhub güncel girişhd film izleBetgarantiExtrabetBetparkizmir escortSnaptikvevobahismatadorbetfixbet girişkralbetCasibomdinimi porn virin sex sitilirimatbet바카라사이트 네임드바카라사이트 카지노사이트Kralbetmarsbahisimajbetmatbetjojobetpadişahbetjojobetjojobetholiganbetcasibom girişmarsbahisonwinbetciocasibomsahabetcasibomcasibom güncel girişStake TürkiyeStake TrStake Girişİzmir Escortcasibomtipobetdinamobetbetturkeyartemisbetartemisbet girişmarsbahismarsbahis güncel girişrestbetrestbet girişwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftgiftcardmall/mygiftgiftcardmall/mygiftwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftwww.giftcardmall.com/mygiftultrabetnakitbahispinbahispinbahis girişkingroyalkingroyal girişotobet girişholiganbetjojobetjojobet güncel girişpadişahbetbetleybettrendbetcasibomcasibom girişdinimi porn virin sex sitiliriAwp ExecutorKing Legacy ScriptRoblox Fisch Scriptgamdomjojobetmarsbahismarsbahis girişfixbetmatadorbet twittertipobetgrandpashabetgrandpashabet güncel girişkulisbetbeşiktaş escortcasibomholiganbetimajbetarmabahis twittertrbetbahsegirtempobetbahisbetaistanbul escortEXTRABETpremiumbahis mevsimbetmarkobet lizbonbet faulbet şutbet meritkingkralbetcasibomtipobetcasibomBeylikdüzü Escortrulet oyna, slot oynazbahiszbahis girişzbahis twitterTipobetsweet bonanza oynavbetmarsbahis girişjojobetmarsbahismarsbahis güncel girişjojobet güncel girişjojobet girişbetcioen iyi su arıtma cihazıbettiltcratosslotcasibom 771 com girişrüyabetrüyabet girişrüyabet güncelmarsbahisgrandbettingtarafbetfixbetbetkomZBAHİSbuy viagra 2025matbetmatbet girişfirma platformutarafbetmatadorbet twittermatadorbetSekabet